Metal Roofing Contractors Blog | McElroy Metal

From Upfront Cost to Lifetime Value: Metal Roofing and Siding Decisions

Written by McElroy Metal | Jun 5, 2025 1:04 PM

The push toward energy-efficient building practices has transformed how we think about metal roofing and siding systems. Rather than viewing initial costs in isolation, savvy contractors and architects now evaluate projects through a life cycle lens that reveals metal's true value proposition.

Energy Efficiency

Metal roofing delivers energy efficiency through three primary mechanisms. The inherent reflective properties of metal panels naturally deflect solar heat away from structures. When manufacturers incorporate cool roof pigments into their coating systems, this reflectivity increases dramatically. These advanced paint technologies create what the industry calls "cool metal roofing" – system with high solar reflectivity and high thermal emittance that work together to reduce heat absorption.

The impact on cooling costs can be substantial. Studies have demonstrated that cool metal roofing can reduce cooling energy expenses by as much as 20%, though specific savings depend on climate conditions, building design, and existing insulation levels. Even darker metal roofing profiles maintain superior reflectivity compared to traditional asphalt shingles.

Above-sheathing ventilation represents another energy efficiency strategy that's gaining traction. ASV creates a ventilated airspace between the roofing material and substrate, allowing heat to move through the space and vent to the atmosphere rather than transferring into the building. In extreme heat conditions, this approach has proven remarkably effective, keeping attic temperatures within five degrees of ambient air compared to shingle roofs that can run nearly 40 degrees hotter.

The sustainability argument extends beyond energy performance. Metal roofing's 60-year lifespan, combined with minimal maintenance requirements, reduces long-term production energy and waste. The material's 100% recyclability means virtually no landfill contribution at end-of-life, making it an inherently sustainable choice that aligns with today's environmental priorities.

Reroofing Strategies: Recover vs. Replacement

The commercial reroofing market has witnessed a significant shift toward recover applications over traditional tear-off and replacement methods. This evolution reflects both practical considerations and code requirements that favor less disruptive approaches.

Metal-over-metal recover systems eliminate the business disruption associated with complete roof removal. While tear-off projects can shut down operations for weeks or months, recover applications allow normal business operations to continue throughout the project timeline. The safety implications are equally compelling – installation crews work on existing roof surfaces rather than exposed framing 20 to 30 feet above ground level.

From a financial perspective, recover projects avoid tear-off and disposal costs while exempting building owners from current International Energy Conservation Code requirements. This exemption can represent significant savings, particularly when new energy standards would otherwise mandate expensive insulation upgrades regardless of the owner's priorities.

The structural enhancement capabilities of recover systems often surprise building owners. Depending on project specifics, multi-span clips can triple wind uplift capacity without removing the original roofing system, addressing updated wind-load requirements that have evolved since original construction. This approach proves far more cost-effective than adding structural framing during tear-off projects.

Navigating Metal Siding Panel Selection

The commercial siding market continues to expand, with metal, brick, and concrete representing 83% of the projected 1.5% annual growth through 2027. Understanding the nuances between vertical and horizontal metal siding orientations helps contractors and architects make informed decisions that align with project goals.

Standing seam panels dominate the vertical siding category due to their concealed fastener systems and superior weather resistance. The interlocking design prevents water intrusion while creating clean, contemporary lines that architects favor for modern commercial projects. These systems particularly excel in harsh climate conditions where wind resistance and minimal maintenance become critical factors.

Insulated metal panels continue to carve out substantial market share by combining structural and thermal performance in a single component. The rigid foam core provides excellent insulation values while the outer metal skin delivers durability and weather protection. Installation speed advantages make IMPs attractive for both new construction and retrofit applications, particularly where energy code compliance and installation speed drive project requirements.

Material selection between aluminum and steel depends heavily on environmental conditions. Aluminum's corrosion resistance makes it an ideal choice for coastal installations, where salt exposure poses ongoing challenges. Steel's superior strength-to-weight ratio better serves applications with significant wind loads or impact concerns. Galvalume coatings on steel provide enhanced protection against rust and weathering in most climate zones.

Gauge selection involves balancing performance requirements against project budgets. Thicker 22 or 24-gauge panels offer superior impact resistance and longevity but command higher material costs. Thinner 26- or 29-gauge options provide adequate performance for low-impact applications, while also improving project economics.

Installation Considerations for Long-Term Performance

Successful metal siding installations begin with proper substrate preparation. Whether working with plywood, metal framing, or exterior-grade sheathing, the substrate must provide stable, even support for the siding system. Moisture barriers become particularly critical in horizontal applications where water management requires more complex detailing.

Fastening strategies vary significantly between exposed and concealed systems. Exposed fastener panels rely on corrosion-resistant screws with neoprene washers, requiring careful spacing to prevent panel warping. Concealed fastener systems utilize clip attachments that accommodate thermal movement, maintaining clean aesthetics and superior weather protection.

Thermal movement accommodation separates successful installations from problematic ones. Metal naturally expands and contracts in response to temperature fluctuations, necessitating installation details that prevent buckling or panel distortion. Slotted fasteners and floating clip systems allow necessary movement while maintaining structural integrity throughout seasonal cycles.

Flashing details at transitions, windows, and doors determine long-term weather resistance. Vertical panel installations typically use J-channels, base trim, and corner treatments for complete weather protection. Horizontal systems require starter strips and transition pieces that maintain proper alignment while managing water drainage.

The selection of high-quality sealants ensures long-term performance at panel joints and system transitions. Polyurethane and silicone-based products offer the flexibility required to accommodate building movement while maintaining effective moisture barriers over extended service periods.

Market Trends and Future Considerations

The evolution toward symmetrical panel designs reflects the industry's focus on installation efficiency and long-term serviceability. Unlike traditional asymmetrical panels that require sequential installation, symmetrical systems allow contractors to start at any roof point and work around penetrations more efficiently. This flexibility reduces installation time while improving overall system quality.

On-site panel production capabilities continue expanding, particularly for projects exceeding 50-foot panel lengths. Site-formed panels, up to 250 feet long, eliminate end-lap joints that represent potential leak points, while reducing installation labor requirements. The approach also cuts packaging and freight costs while eliminating job-site waste from crating materials.

Energy code evolution continues driving market preferences toward higher-performance systems. Recover applications that exempt projects from current IECC requirements provide immediate cost advantages, but forward-thinking designers increasingly specify systems that exceed minimum standards to future-proof their projects.

The weathertightness warranty market remains contentious within the industry. While some manufacturers heavily promote these products, experienced contractors often recommend investing in quality installation practices rather than warranty coverage. Proper installation typically eliminates the leak sources that warranties address, making the additional cost difficult to justify on well-executed projects.